[ http://jira.qos.ch/browse/LBCLASSIC-45?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system... ] Joern Huxhorn commented on LBCLASSIC-45: ---------------------------------------- This might be true, depending on how the functionality in question would be implemented. I agree with you that always extracting the caller data wouldn't be an option at all - even though I must admit that I leave this option on, even in production systems, since performance is still quite acceptable ;) I'd suggest to configure globally if caller data and/or thread name should be extracted for LoggingEvents instead of on a per appender option. This would mean that caller data would be extracted in the Logger (instead of in LoggingEvent) if requested by the configuration. Beside solving the problem you mentioned (e.g. passing LoggingEvent to another Thread without calling getCallerData first) it would also simplify Logger, LoggingEvent and Appenders, reducing the chance of potential problems, like forgetting to call prepareForDeferredProcessing()/getThreadName() or getCallerData in appenders even though it would be needed. Another, more or less similar, point is the lazy initialization of threadName. It has the same problem, i.e. it mustn't be called on a different thread for the first time, and does have a performance impact. One of my original points of this RFE was to remove potential pitfalls related to IMO unnecessary complexity in LoggingEvent. While performance is obviously the most important aspect of LoggingEvent creation (which isn't optimal at the moment because of eager creation of formatted message in c'tor), ease and simplicity of use should be a close second ;) So what's the general opinion on a globally configured ExtractCallerData and Extract/ResolveThreadName?

Suggestion: Make LoggingEvent dumber, Logger more intelligent -------------------------------------------------------------

Key: LBCLASSIC-45 URL: http://jira.qos.ch/browse/LBCLASSIC-45 Project: logback-classic Issue Type: Improvement Components: Other Affects Versions: unspecified Environment: Operating System: All Platform: All Reporter: Joern Huxhorn Assignee: Logback dev list Priority: Minor

This change would introduce incompatibilities with previous versions but would increase general logging performance and decrease size of serialized events. After I have turned you off sufficiently ;), let me explain my idea: At the moment, LoggingEvent is handling it's own initialization. It even contains measures against manipulation after initialization in that a call of a setter results in an IllegalStateException if the attribute has already been initialized before. Instead, I'd suggest that LoggingEvent is changed into a dumb data container with getter and setters for all it's attributes. If it's really necessary to have a semi-const LoggingEvent I'd suggest to define LoggingEvent as an interface containing only the getters of the attributes and an implementation LoggingEventImpl that implements LoggingEvent including getters and setters. This communicates the *intent* that LoggingEvents aren't supposed to be modified but nothing more. It would still be possible to change e.g. the content of an array like argumentArray. Even if the getter would return a copy of the contained array, generating heat in the process, it would *still* be possible to brutally manipulate the LoggingEvent using java.lang.reflection setAccessible(true) so it's just not possible to guarantee constness. Instead of having a pseudo-const LoggingEvent let's dump the constness altogether and make it a dumb data container that contains no logic at all. This would instead be moved to the Logger class. I'd also suggest to remove formattedMessage and change the argumentArray to String[]. This is possible because logback-classic/slf4j promises formatted message, not LoggingEvent. It would increase performance because a Logger would simply create a LoggingEvent without performing a possibly unnecessary formatting of the message. Creation of LoggingEvents should be as fast and simple as possible, obviously. The formatting of the message should/would instead be performed in the appender (or, more generally, user of the event) if required. A serializing appender, an xml appender (e.g. using java.beans.XMLEncoder) or a socket appender would *not* require a formatted message, executing significantly faster than before. The argumentArray should be String[] to securely prevent java.io.NotSerializableException in the serializer and . java.lang.ClassNotFoundException in the deserializer. LoggerRemoteView and LoggerContextRemoteView should be changed the same way as LoggingEvent, i.e. just data container, logic moved to Logger, for similar reasons. I have to admit, though, that I currently don't understand the reason the LoggingEvent needs to know about LoggerContext beside resolving of the Logger name. I couldn't find code that uses LoggerContextRemoteView.getPropertyMap(), beside loading and saving it. So I think it may be possible that LoggerRemoteView isn't really necessary and could be removed from LoggingEvent... remembering the Logger name instead. fqnOfLoggerClass could be omitted because the CallerData would be created in the Logger where fqnOfLoggerClass is known. And last but not least I'd also change Level into an java.lang.Enum. I don't expect that all this will be done but I wanted to suggest it nevertheless because it would both increase performance and produce cleaner code. Breaking compatibility would IMHO be worth it - after all, logback isn't 1.0, yet ;) If you are interested I'd volunteer to implement those changes, after signing http://logback.qos.ch/cla.txt of course. Keywords: Inversion of Control (IoC), separation of concerns, KISS principle Related bugs: http://bugzilla.qos.ch/show_bug.cgi?id=100 http://bugzilla.qos.ch/show_bug.cgi?id=118 http://bugzilla.slf4j.org/show_bug.cgi?id=70

-- This message is automatically generated by JIRA. - If you think it was sent incorrectly contact one of the administrators: http://jira.qos.ch/secure/Administrators.jspa - For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira